Why Me?
Eventually, after gathering the courage to tell a few close friends, I came out to the new staff worker of the organization in the second week of last October. She works for the national organization, having started just this summer at Roanoke College. We met at Mill Mountain Coffee, like we had a few times before. I was nervous. She was the first person to whom I was telling the truth who was not extremely close to me already. I told her that I had studied and prayed a lot about this issue, and came to the conclusion that homosexuality is not a sin. During this conversation, I also confided that I had been in a relationship for over a month with another student on campus. She responded with support, but said she would consult her boss, read, and pray about the issue. She never asked how where I felt like sexual sin affected me. Hearing that I was merely dating a man was enough to elicit an investigation. For the first time, my leadership began to be questioned, not because of how I worked or my faith in God, but because she now knew my orientation was different. I left that meeting trying not to worry about how things would turn out.
The Thursday after our Fall Break, I met with the staff worker again, and I was faced with a choice: I could either end my leadership and continue my homosexual relationship or break up with my boyfriend and take a break from leadership to reevaluate myself. She told me that because I seemed firm on my beliefs and intent on remaining in my relationship, that I could no longer be on leadership with the organization. My heart sank. I felt sick to my stomach, but I tried not to show it. I had jumped off the proverbial cliff, but wasn't hitting any water. I thought of all the time I had put into the organization, all the friends I had made, all of the time working and rehearsing, and I just felt hurt that I was being told that I could no longer continue. I could no longer be a leader because I refused to break up with my boyfriend and pursue a life of chaste single-hood. I told her, despite my hurt and my frustration and my anger that I would help with the transition for the sake of the community that I loved and the ministry that I had put so much time into. I didn't want to abandon them, even though I felt abandoned myself.
I reflected on the situation, vaguely knowing that the organization called for homosexuals to pursue a life of celibacy. I thought of Paris's book, as she described the call to celibacy (or in my instance, the call to be single):
"When sexual morality becomes an idol, it dominates the landscape, prioritizing the choice for or against sexual intimacy as the choice that matters most; the options become diametrically opposed: be holy or be a whore, choose God or pleasure, be a disciple or hedonist. When people make sexual decisions, however, the choice is rarely (if ever) so stark."
Then why did it feel so stark now? I was never even asked how I felt about my own sexual holiness or how my relationship with my boyfriend impacted my relationship with God. I kept asking myself why this was the deciding factor for the discontinuation of my leadership. Why me? I suppose I chose to be a whore in the eyes of the organization, but I felt that I had not compromised my relationship with God, but only became closer with Him by being true and authentic. I didn't mean to put myself in a position of discrimination, yet it happened to me nonetheless.
I reminded myself once more: I am firstly and foremost a child of God.
I was predictably torn up over this news, so fueled by hurt, frustration, and the green tea I just drank, I went on a coming out spree, letting some of my friends know, and eventually calling my mom. While my mom is loving and supportive of me, her response is best described as hesitant. After telling her, I heard silence on the other end of the phone for at least twenty seconds. When my mom finally found words to use, she muttered, "Okay...." and proceeded to be silent once more. After what felt like an eternity, she asked, "Are you sure?" I laughed nervously. "Of course, I'm sure, Mom. I wouldn't be telling you otherwise." Now, I find her response hilarious, but at the time, it was merely a relief, a slog of weights off my shoulder.
The next Sunday, I came out to my small group both as homosexual and with the news that I could no longer be the small group leader. Sitting in Kresge lounge dispersed among the numerous couches, my friends were gathered. I had to coax some of them to be there despite homework. When I shared my news, it felt like a blur. I can't even remember what I said exactly. I know they were supportive of me, but when we got to figuring out how to proceed as a small group, things got tricky. I could no longer be leader while our group was attached to the organization. We discussed breaking apart and continuing to meet as usual, but some people were uncomfortable with that. One by one, my friends discussed in front of me what to do with my role as their leader, ultimately submitting to the decision to remove me from leadership. I felt frustrated that so few people would take a stand for their beliefs. They wanted to avoid making waves, avoid fracturing the community. I wanted much of the same, but I also wanted justice. We tried to figure out who would step up as my replacement, but no one did.

The following Thursday was the final time I could lead worship. When I came out to the staff worker, I was loosely aware of the organization's doctrine on homosexuality, and while I somewhat expected that I would no longer be allowed to lead, I had hoped desperately for a different solution. There are a several issues with this decision in particular.
Firstly, there have been mixed conceptions between myself and the staff worker and her boss as to whether I stepped down or was kicked off leadership. I was given a choice: the choice to either end my relationship with my boyfriend and take a break from leadership or discontinue leadership entirely. That is neither a fair nor reasonable choice for anyone in leadership. My leadership position was terminated involuntarily and unjustly.
What especially stung is that my leadership position was terminated immediately, rather than at a point of review or renewal such as at the end of a semester. Being up front singing at worship in front of 50-60 students made me a very visible leader. I couldn't just disappear and not have it be noticed. Removal mid-semester made the end of my leadership all the more public and humiliating. Other students have had issues with leadership expectations in the past, and have either chosen to not reapply at the end of the year (in the case of one who continued having sex with his girlfriend) or been disallowed during the reapplication process. Their reasons for ending my leadership immediately was that I was no longer contemplating this issue of homosexuality as a sin, and I had landed on a side different from their doctrine. I had to ask myself: why allow students to investigate and figure things out regarding sexuality, if only one conclusion is accepted?
Having been in all of the major leadership levels of the chapter, I had never signed anything that says I cannot act upon my personal beliefs regarding homosexuality. All leaders of the organization agree to the organization's basis of faith and leadership expectations. The leadership expectations call for relational purity, described as committing to the vaguely described "sexual purity, abstaining from all sexually immoral behavior." Being in a homosexual relationship does not go against this. Nowhere in their constitution, leadership expectations, basis of faith, or any of the leadership training I had ever been a part of ever expressed a belief against homosexuality. Thus, based on my commitment, there was not a reason to terminate my leadership position. As a side note, after browsing through the organization's website for over an hour, I could not ever find a link to the official theological statement on the issue. I had to have someone send it to me. In fact, the organization purposely shields their doctrines from non-leaders on their website. This lack of transparency is incredibly alarming. Why hide what you believe in? If you hold particular beliefs as a faith organization, there should be no reason to fear sharing them.

Leadership expectations are a regular point of contention within the organization. People come from different backgrounds and struggle with various sins, often hiding their struggles to maintain a perfect image for the sake of the chapter. I hid that I was not struggling with sexuality, and others hid relationships, sexual sin, partying, gossiping, lying, etc. in order to keep up this image of perfection. Leadership expectations are regularly broken by all of their leaders, because everyone is sinful. This organization, through its disciplinary actions, took liberties to weigh its own hidden values, ultimately putting some sins above others (a rarely contested statement in the Bible and among Protestants is that no sin is greater than another).
One of the foundational appeals of the organization was that it accepts Christians, regardless of background. I grew up ELCA, am at an ELCA college, and yet my denominational beliefs came into direct contradiction with the organization's hidden theologies. It appeared that the organization was dishonest about its non-denominational status. By pushing its doctrine, the organization defined its leadership expectations in a discriminatory manner.
Amid the process of ending my leadership, I met with the regional director of the organization, Jennifer. This was the staff worker's boss and with whom she consulted with after I came out to her. We met in the back room of the Chaplain’s Office. I had scoured the organization’s website and doctrines and was prepared to point out the flaws in the decision. I carried a folder of papers with me. Jennifer and I faced each other, and the staff worker sat to the side, silently observing the whole time. Since this decision came from above our campus, I was ready to face someone who held more stake in the decision to remove me as a leader. I felt like I could only hold our staff worker somewhat responsible, since she was both new and unsure of how to proceed. I immediately felt uncomfortable, not know how to best seek answers. I asked why I was not fit to be a leader, and Jennifer referred to the fact that being in a homosexual relationship is a recurring sin and goes against leadership expectations. That didn’t make sense though. Leadership expectations did not include homosexuality, and she admitted that they were not as expansive as they should be.
She added that if I was willing to submit to the organization's beliefs, regardless of my own, then I could be allowed on leadership. So, I concluded, even if I believe differently about homosexuality but act in accordance to the organization, then I would be allowed to lead. I asked how this works for heterosexuals who believe similarly to myself. Jennifer asserted that as long as leaders act according to policy, then they can believe differently. I found this distinctly hypocritical when running a faith-based organization, especially when students sign the Basis of Faith when coming onto leadership. I was growing increasingly frustrated. My hands shook as I gripped my notated papers. Another group began walking into the room for another meeting. We moved to the staff worker’s tiny office, and I sat down in a tiny office chair, ready for our match to continue.
I needed to stay composed. I was the lone person standing up for myself. I had realized no one else was going to fight this battle except for me. I pointed to statements within the doctrine on multiculturalism, where the organization states that it welcomes people from all cultures and backgrounds. Jennifer asserted that the organization's definition of culture is one that does not include sexual orientation or gender identity. That’s it. I was getting angry. Considering that gender and sexual orientation and their roles in society are so ingrained in our culture, I found this to be ludicrous. Clearly, Jennifer's sense of heterosexuality and a traditional view of marriage are part of her culture. You cannot have one half without the other, unless to say that homosexuality does not exist. I told her this, but I was starting to lose my composure. Being my own activist was even harder than I thought it would be.

At one point, Jennifer posited that some leadership expectations weigh differently than others. I sat in my seat gape-jawed, shocked that she could so ignorantly admit that the organization sees sins weighed differently. I was feeling all of the hurt from my rejection, frustration from being unable to convince someone of their hypocrisy, and anger at the injustice occurring before me. Tears came to my eyes. I was illogically and ignorantly being rejected for merely dating a guy. I shook my head and declared that I was done. The staff worker suggested we end with a prayer. I obliged, though I just wanted to leave. I can barely remember what unconsoling prayer was uttered in that back office. Unsurprisingly, I left that meeting in a state of unease and distaste for this hypocrisy. I was shocked by Jennifer's words and turned off by her cold demeanor. I have often heard Christians say that they "love" homosexuals by doing everything they can to get them to repent. I had always been taught to love God firstly with all my heart, soul, and mind, and then to love my neighbors as myself. I didn't feel much love from Jennifer. I felt judgment, unjust decisions, and speck of dust in my eye. I couldn't help but see a plank in Jennifer's.
I felt hurt personally, discriminated against, and unjustly treated by the national organization. I have mostly been met with support by everyone on campus and in the chapter, whether agreeing or disagreeing with my beliefs. Ultimately, this decision was not supported by the people of this chapter. They knew me and knew that my orientation did not hurt my ability to lead.
My favorite Lutheran, Martin Luther, wrote, "Be a sinner, and let your sins be strong, but let your trust in Christ be stronger, and rejoice in Christ who is victor over sin, death, and the world. No sin can separate us from Him, even if we were to kill or commit adultery thousands of times each day."
I can't help but think that this is how Christian leaders need to be viewed, not as perfect individuals, but as sinners. This organization was unable to trust that their perceived sin of homosexuality would be overcome by grace. Wherever your beliefs lie regarding this, if you believe that any sin holds enough power to contaminate a chapter, or damage a leadership role, then you are not truly trusting in the Gospel. Ultimately, this is where I see that the fallacy of this organization lies.
That being said, this is not an issue that is unique in many ways. This organization has historically been a point of contention on campuses in regards to this issue. In my case, there are not many instances of gay leaders being kicked off leadership; many chose to resign (still resulting in administrative investigations). I have thus been thrust into the precarious role I am in now, both a member and protector of the community, a follower of Jesus, and activist for this injustice. I feel empowered to keep this discrimination from happening again. Further, I feel empowered to ensure that there is a Christian community on the Roanoke College campus where LGBT students may feel welcomed. As long as LGBT students are restricted from leadership in this organization, it will never be an organization that can truly allow for them to explore their faith. I was very unsure of how to contend with this discrimination, yet I believe that the organization is founded upon, among many good practices, several dishonest and discriminatory practices.
Meanwhile, I was more certain than ever of my beliefs. My mantra hadn't changed. I am firstly, and foremost a child of God. Yet, I came to add, that I am God's beautiful and perfect creation. He has made no mistakes. And God’s creation is GOOD.